Article by Luca Enriques and Martin Gelter
The European framework for creditor protection has undergone a remarkable transformation in recent years. While the European Court of Justice's Centros case and its progeny have given European Union businesses free choice with respect to the state of incorporation, and hence to the substantive corporate law regime, the European Insolvency Regulation has introduced uniform conflict-of-law rules for insolvencies. However, this regime has opened up some forum shopping opportunities for corporate debtors. Both regulatory competition in corporate law and forum shopping in bankruptcy law have been discussed in the United States for years, while they are relatively new territory in the European Union.
This article attempts to pull together the two emerging discussions and analyzes possible consequences for the relationship between shareholders, managers, and creditors in European corporations. We argue that in the absence of evidence of either a race to the top or the bottom, we cannot rule out adverse consequences of either regulatory competition in corporate law or forum shopping in bankruptcy. However, the discussion so far has largely considered only the consequences of the first type of regulatory arbitrage while neglecting the second. Hence, the issue of the “insolvencification” of corporate law rules has been brought up in order to enable national policymakers to impose their respective ideas about creditor protection on firms. We suggest that such attempts may be futile.
First, relabeling is possible only to a rather limited degree, and second, while restricting the scope for corporate law arbitrage, relabeling increases the incentives for forum shopping in bankruptcy. Ultimately, relabeling may even backfire, leading to a higher degree of bankruptcy forum shopping to avoid the very rules that have been insolvencified.
About the Author
Luca Enriques. Professor of Law, University of Bologna; European Corporate Governance Institute. The author can be reached at luca.enriques@unibo.it.
Martin Gelter. Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration. The author can be reached at martin.gelter@wu-wien.ac.at.
Citation
81 Tul. L. Rev. 577 (2007)